Blog

Custom Automation vs. Off-the-Shelf (OTS) Automation: Which is Right for You?

Custom automation vs OTS

When you have a plethora of options to choose from, things get confusing. 

But we are here to help you understand everything about Custom Automation and Off-the-Shelf Automation. First, let’s understand the basic difference between them, before we dive deeper.

Key Differences Between Custom and Off-the-Shelf Automation

Custom Automation

  • They are tailored solutions which fit your exact needs. 
  • Investment is more compared to Off the shelf automation.
  • It offers long time efficiency due to the custom build which suits your business.
  • Best for Unique or complex processes.

Off-the-Shelf Automation (OTS)

  • They are prebuilt solutions designed for general use cases.
  • Best of standardized processes.
  • It is cost effective but has limited scalability.

Understand Automation Solutions: What Are Your Options?

What is Custom Automation?

Custom automation simply means designing and building custom machinery or solutions to perfectly fit the custom requirements of a business.

This  automation solution is ideal for unique processes, technologies and complex production lines. 

Benefits of Custom Automation

  • Improves the quality of your products: Custom automation fine tunes your production lines, thus helping you produce improved quality products. 
  • Higher throughput and efficiency: Since its custom made, the production automatically removes downtime or other inefficiencies which would otherwise occur due to OTS automation.
  • Increased response time: Traditional manufacturing processes could take time to complete an order due to the various manual operations needed. This is completely eradicated due to the faster response time the automated machines have. 

What is Off-the-shelf (OTS) Automation?

Off-the-shelf Automation simply means ready-to-use machineries or solutions made for general industry use. It does not have a specific use case. It requires minimal setup and no custom engineering and is common in industries with standardized processes. 

Benefits of OTS Automation

  • It’s cost effective. But it can be more expensive over time.
  • It’s quick to implement, but will be inflexible with any changes made in the current process.
  • Limited scalability due to its general nature of use.

Key Factors to Consider: Custom vs. Off-the-Shelf Automation

1. Engineering & Design Complexity

Custom Automation

  • It requires intensive design to match the custom requirements according to your needs.
  • Complex engineering needed to perfect the automation solution to be in complete sync of your production line.
  • It is developed from scratch, hence has no limits to how good it can be made.
  • Scalability is possible for unforeseen factors like; new development in technology, sudden increase in demand of goods being produced etc.

Off-the-shelf Automation

  • Since it is made for generic purposes, no complex engineering needed to create such machinery.
  • It works with existing pre-defined processes.
  • Any change in the pre-defined conditions will result in unexpected delays in the production process due to the nature of the automation.

2. Cost & Budget Considerations

Custom Automation

  • It has a higher upfront cost as it is made according to the custom requirements of any process.
  • Due to the custom nature, it has long-term saving opportunities as the whole production process has increased potential, reduced or no downtime, ability to adapt due to which no time is wasted, thus saving money or potential losses due to it.

Off-the-shelf Automation

  • Lower initial costs due to pre-built solutions already available.
  • Losses may occur due to machine downtime due to lack of adaptability to changing conditions.

3. Implementation & Deployment Speed

Custom Automation

  • Research, design & development takes the majority of the time. Hence the time taken to implement this into your production line is more.
  • But due to this, the effectiveness and efficiency of the production line increases 10x times due to custom nature.

Off-the-shelf Automation

  • As these are pre-built, the time taken to install the machinery is less, work can be started quickly, thus giving faster ROI. 

4. Integration with Existing Systems

Automation doesn’t work in isolation—it needs to integrate seamlessly with your existing infrastructure. Whether you’re upgrading production lines or adding new robotic systems, compatibility is key.

  • Custom Automation: Designed from the ground up to match your operational workflow, custom solutions ensure seamless connectivity with existing machines, control systems, and enterprise software. This reduces inefficiencies and minimizes downtime during the transition.
  • Off-the-Shelf Automation: These solutions are typically designed to follow industry standards, making them easier to integrate with widely used systems. However, they might not fit perfectly with legacy equipment, requiring modifications or adapters to function properly.

One key challenge with off-the-shelf automation is data exchange compatibility. Many manufacturers use proprietary communication protocols, which may not be supported by standard automation solutions.

 A custom-built system, on the other hand, can be designed to communicate with both legacy and modern technology, eliminating bottlenecks in data flow.

Beyond the Basics: Strategic Considerations for Long-Term Success

Automation decisions shouldn’t just focus on immediate cost or deployment time. Businesses need to think ahead—considering factors like compliance, competition, and sustainability—to ensure long-term success.

Regulatory & Compliance Readiness

Industries such as pharmaceuticals, aerospace, and food production operate under strict government regulations. Automation systems in these industries must comply with specific safety, quality, and data reporting standards.

  • Off-the-Shelf Automation: These solutions are often designed to meet general industry standards, but they may not fully align with highly specialized compliance requirements. Additional modifications may be needed, adding hidden costs.
  • Custom Automation: Can be designed to fully comply with industry-specific regulations from day one, reducing the risk of non-compliance penalties and ensuring smooth audits.

If your business operates in a regulated industry, choosing automation that ensures compliance from the start can save significant time and effort later.

Competitive Edge & Differentiation

Automation is not just about being efficient. It’s about staying one step ahead of the competition. Just like, too many cooks spoil the broth, similarly, too many off-the-shelf machinery will leave you with little to no room to gain an advantage.

  • Custom automation allows you to develop machineries that competitors can’t easily replicate. Be it faster production speeds, lower defect rates or other unique manufacturing capabilities, competitors wont be able to replicate these, as it is custom made to match your needs, and not theirs.
  • Off-the-shelf systems often provide a level playing field, meaning competitors can easily implement the same solution. So, the competition then comes down to the basic factors like, the quality of your product, the rate at which you can finish your orders etc. 

Companies that rely heavily on innovation—such as high-tech manufacturing, medical devices, or specialized automotive components—often benefit more from custom-built solutions that enhance their competitive edge.

Sustainability & Energy Efficiency

Sustainability is becoming a major focus for modern industries, with companies looking for ways to reduce waste, lower energy consumption, and minimize environmental impact. Automation can play a key role in helping you achieve these goals.

  • Off-the-Shelf: Many pre-built automation systems are optimized for standard energy efficiency, but they may not fully align with a company’s green initiatives.
  • Custom Automation: These can be engineered to use less power, reduce material waste, and optimize energy-intensive processes, making operations more sustainable. So, there is no limit to how energy efficient these systems can be.

For companies looking to reduce their carbon footprint or meet corporate sustainability goals, custom automation can be a smart investment that pays off in both regulatory compliance and cost savings.

The Role of Data & Smart Automation in Decision-Making

Automation is no longer just about moving parts—it’s about how efficiently data is captured, analyzed, and used to optimize performance. Modern businesses need to ensure their automation strategy is data-driven.

Leveraging Data for Process Optimization

Automation systems today collect vast amounts of data, but how effectively that data is used determines overall efficiency.

  • Custom Automation: It can be designed with real-time data collection, predictive analytics, and machine learning algorithms that adapt and improve efficiency over time. Due to this, it becomes easier to predict things like issues in the system, thus helping you perform any repairs without increasing its downtime.
  • Off-the-Shelf Automation: Many pre-configured solutions come with basic analytics that provide operational insights but may lack deep customization for specific business needs. Thus, downtime in such machines increases due to lack of predictive analytics.

By integrating advanced monitoring systems, businesses can identify inefficiencies, predict failures before they occur, and make real-time adjustments to maximize productivity.

AI & Machine Learning in Automation

Artificial intelligence is reshaping automation by making machines smarter and more adaptable. AI-driven automation can self-optimize, reducing downtime and enhancing output quality.

  • Off-the-shelf solutions are starting to integrate basic AI-driven monitoring, but full adaptability is limited.
  • Custom automation allows businesses to incorporate AI at a deeper level, enabling machines to learn from past performance and make real-time decisions.

Future-Proofing: How to Make the Right Long-Term Investment?

Automation is a major investment, and businesses need to think beyond immediate ROI. The best solutions are those that align with future growth, industry trends, and evolving technology.

How to Assess Future Flexibility

Before committing to an automation solution, ask these simple questions:
✅ Will this system accommodate future process expansions or modifications?
✅ Can it integrate with new software and technologies as they emerge?
✅ Does it allow for easy customization as business needs evolve?

If the answer is no, you may end up replacing the system sooner than expected, leading to higher long-term costs.

Final Thought: Choosing the Right Path for Growth

The decision between off-the-shelf and custom automation isn’t just about price—it’s about long-term efficiency, adaptability, and staying competitive.

✅ If you need quick deployment with lower upfront costs, off-the-shelf might be best.
✅ If you want a solution optimized for unique business needs and scalability, custom automation is worth the investment.
✅ If you’re looking for a balance between cost and flexibility, consider a modular or hybrid approach.

So, it comes down to the best option that suits your needs, while also thinking about the future of your business. 

How Can FenBotics Help You?

Choosing the right automation partner is crucial for your business’s success. At FenBotics, we understand that every operation is unique, and we’re here to provide solutions that fit your specific needs.

Tailored Automation Solutions

We specialize in designing specialized machinery that works flawlessly with your existing processes. Our goal is to increase efficiency and precision while avoiding disturbances. Whether you want to automate a single task or completely rebuild a manufacturing line, our team can develop and execute gear that exactly fits your needs.

Enhancing Existing Systems.

Already have equipment in place? No worries, we also provide retrofitting and upgrading services to improve the reliability and performance of your existing systems. We examine your current setup and find areas for improvement before implementing solutions that improve uptime and product quality.

Data-Driven Decision Making

In today’s data-centric world, having access to accurate and meaningful information is vital. Our expertise in Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE) tracking and data collection ensures you have the insights needed to drive performance improvements. We start by standardizing your processes to guarantee the data you collect is both accurate and actionable.

Ready to explore how custom automation can transform your operations? Let’s work together to create a solution that’s as unique as your business.